Apple Wins Courtroom Ruling Throwing Out $308.5-Million Patent Verdict
Apple persuaded a federal decide to throw out a $308.5 million (roughly Rs. 2,298 crores) jury verdict it misplaced to a privately-held licensing agency for infringing a patent related to digital rights administration.
In a Thursday night time choice, US District Decide Rodney Gilstrap mentioned Customized Media Communications LLC (PMC) deliberately delayed submitting its utility with the US Patent and Trademark Workplace, hoping to acquire a bigger payout.
“This courtroom takes very critically the prospect of disturbing the unanimous verdict of a duly empaneled jury,” however PMC’s “deliberate technique of delay” was a “aware and egregious misuse of the statutory patent system,” Gilstrap wrote.
PMC, primarily based in Sugar Land, Texas, claimed in its 2015 lawsuit that the FairPlay software program utilized in Apple’s iTunes service and App Retailer to decrypt motion pictures, music and apps infringed its patent obtained in 2012.
However the decide, who sits in Marshall, Texas, accepted Apple’s protection of “prosecution laches,” which may block a patent holder from imposing a patent after an unreasonable and unexplained delay. Gilstrap mentioned PMC’s delay lasted a few years.
Jurors had discovered Cupertino, California-based Apple liable to PMC on March 19, after a one-week trial.
“PMC respectfully disagrees with Decide Gilstrap’s ruling and plans to attraction,” its lawyer Douglas Kline of Goodwin Procter mentioned in an e mail.
Apple didn’t instantly reply to requests for remark.
PMC’s patent utility dated to functions filed within the 1980s.
Gilstrap mentioned PMC employed a so-called “submarine” patent technique, submitting serial functions after which holding its patent portfolio “hidden” till business broadly adopted the underlying expertise.
He mentioned PMC would demand licensing charges or allege infringement solely after it believed infringement was widespread.
A June 1 choice by the federal appeals courtroom dealing with patent circumstances made it simpler to problem submarine patents.
© Thomson Reuters 2021